Smart-people traps
A friend of mine recently introduced me to a concept she calls “smart-people traps.” It’s a loose idea, but still useful. A smart-person trap is a limiting situation that is particularly common or tempting for smart people to get themselves into. And given that you’re reading this blog, you’re probably a smart person, so I thought I’d pass these along, lest you find yourself in a pickle.
1. The Professions
Smart people go into The Professions (you know, white collar work: lawyer, doctor, banker, career-track desk jockey) for any number of reasons: they are tempted by the rewards, or they are pressured by family and culture, or they cannot leave the security of a pre-defined track, or they are unwilling to explore themselves enough to see an individual course. The problem is that The Professions are a grind, and for many there is no passion or purpose, no vision or meaning, no intuitive individual truth. And if you’ve ever been trapped doing work that has no meaning for you, you know how soul-sucking this can be.
2. Academics
Smart people are good at school, and so they are tempted to stay in school their whole lives. The problem with this is that for most academics, they get into a spiral of irrelevance and isolation from the rest of the world.
3. Politics
Smart people often want to use their gifts to help the world, and politics seems like a good path. The trap is that in order to change the world through politics, you must gain power, and the game of gaining power will fuck you up for sure.
4. Critical thinking
Smart people generally get very educated, and higher education (in the US at least) teaches only critical thinking. Smart people spend all their formative years getting rewarded for finding problems, for focusing on the negative. They leave school thinking that the way to be useful and show your smarts is to point out why things won’t work, rather than using some of those smart to find a way forward. Of course, critical thinking IS useful, but it is not a complete toolbox. (Consider, for example, how useful it is to know how to do creative thinking.) The problem is that most smart people have only one tool, but because they don’t know any better, they operate as if their toolbox is full.
The thing about traps is that once you see them, you can avoid them. So let’s hear it: what other smart people traps can you think of?
July, 2008















