Yesterday Josh and I went back to school. We packed a lunch, complete with Capri Suns and note from Mom telling us we were her special boys. Actually, we’d been invited to be guests in Christopher Simmons‘ Graphic Design 2 class at CCA.
“Professor” Simmons had given them the raw text from our manifestos (Dear Bosses, How to Clean out Your Desk, and How to Be a Better Lover) and asked them to turn it into a designed piece. Yesterday was the review of their conceptual directions, and we played the role of (friendly) client. There were about 10 students in the class, and we were inspired to see the courage of their explorations. No one’s stuff looked like anyone else’s, which is more than you can say for most of the stuff coming out of design shops today. Thumbs up.
It was obvious they’d put in a lot of thinking already, so it was easy to have a useful conversation. But we think we could have been more clear, so we’re gonna give it another shot here:
Make sure each concept you show is actually different from the rest.
It often happens that a client will want to see a few different design directions. Yesterday a lot of students showed three directions—one real idea, and two watered-down variations of that idea. This won’t actually work when there’s money involved. The first problem is that you’re putting all your eggs in one basket, because three directions so similar will live and die together. The second problem is that the client may feel like they’re not getting their money’s worth. And the third, and most important, problem is that this kind of creative shortcut will erode your creativity in the long run.
Commit to the concept
There were some great ideas yesterday. But very few students took the ideas as far as they could go. Lots of students were compelled to find inspiration in other formats—manuals, boxes, gifts, official forms, letters, etc—and so they made their directions “like” those formats. This is a good, good thing. But we think it’s more powerful to take it all the way. So don’t make it “like a manual,” make a manual. Don’t make it “like a gift,” make a gift. Don’t make it “like a box,” make a box. Why fake it?
Make sure you know your concepts and can talk about them
Articulating ideas about something as subtle as communication is not easy, but it’s ridiculously important, precisely because the stuff is so damn subtle. While a concept is still just a concept, everyone is going to need help seeing what you see. And not just what you see, but why you see it that way. And not just why you see it that way, but why others should too. Here’s one last thought: if you can’t articulate your concept in a way that makes sense, that’s a big sign that maybe it doesn’t make sense.